What You Said: Reader Comments
April 24, 2008

Some of you disagree with me, I LOVE that. Keep the comments coming, I really like to see what each of you has to say about the show, the contestants and my posts.

David Archuleta is soooooooooooooooooooo cute I just know that he’s going to win!!!!!
Artfanatic2, 13, MN

I also thought that Jordin Sparks and Chris Brown's song No air was good but I think they were lip synching! I absoloutley love Miley Cyrus'es performance. She is AH-mazing. Thanks for reading!
btflygirl, 11, ny

I totally agree that Michael Johns left American Idol too soon! He wasn't my favorite but I think he deserved to go farther. My two favorite guys are Jason Castro, I love his voice and choice of songs, and David Archuleta, although he is only 17 I think he has the voice and the desire to win it all!
luv2sing26, 12, OH

I do not like Brooke White. But everyone that likes her has to at least say she was a little off key or pitchy. And Jason Castro has got a too soft average voice. And not that the contest is about looks but his hair is not even real! David Archuleta is my favorite! But I don't think he will win because everyone says he is too young. David Cook is the fav of my mom. He is so good. He makes everything his own and it is always something new. Kristy Lee Cook does not deserve to be out already! I realize you cannot win with two good performences but others like Syesha and Jason Castro should be out before her. And last but not least... Carly Smithson! She is my sister's favorite. But I like her too. She does not deserve to be out or even in the bottom three.
KPFan

I loved David Cook's performence on Tuesday, April 15. It was amazing and he blew me away when he sang "Always Be My Baby". Good luck David! I was also sad to see Brooke White in the bottom the the following night. I love you Brooke, your talented.
CHEERxGiRLx00, 10, CT

I'm probably a little old for your web site, but my younger sister is a huge fan and has been sharing things she found interesting on MissOandFriends.com. I didn't get to see Kristy Lee Cook's audition, although now that I hear it was amazing I wish I could have watched it. I thought it was time for her to go all along, until country night. I really felt that her version of 'Anyway' by Martina McBride was her best performance. I thought she really stepped up during country week and even felt that during her Mariah Carey performance that maybe I had judged her too quickly, because she really could sing all along and I think she was just starting to prove that. That being said, Kristy Lee Cook was not my favorite, David Archuleta is! I was shocked to see that you think his attitude is becoming annoying. He has an amazing voice and is adorable, but he also choses songs that express his faith. I have a lot of respect for him and I hope he wins or at least gets a contract. I'm just confused about how anyone could find him annoying? Maybe you can pinpoint it for me!? To me his attitude has always seemed upbeat, but not in a way that made him seem cocky or arrogant. And I agree that Brooke's performance was the worst and if it was judged on one performance, as it often seems to be, she should have been out.
Tiffany, 19, Ohio

Tiffany, thanks for writing in! I just think he's a little bit too peppy, but I guess that's a silly thing to complain about! Keep reading the blog and send me more comments. I appreciate the emails!

It's me Madison the girl who emailed before and said I Loved David Archuleta (BTW I still love him). I did some research on him and there was an interview given from some of his friends They said he is exactly the same in real life as he is on the T.V. show so he is not faking that sweet, shy and humble attitude. Oh, and I found out he is mormon. Your blog rocks.
Madison

I think that Christy Lee Cook should have left before Michael Johns did. I LOVED his Aussie accent! He says that he is coming out with a cd for his fans. That means ME!!!!!!
Kaitlyn

I really want brooke to go! But I think David Archuleta will win! Not because I love him, but that and he can sing amazingly! I also think the top to will come down down to David Cook and David Archuleta.
Authorgirl434, 11, OH

If you have a comment for me, make sure you send it my way. Don't forget to tune in next week.

Tuned in 24/7,
Idol Fanatic